A Glossary for the Emerging Democratic Health Care Debate
Reprinted from The New York Times, 2/19/19, written by Margot Sanger-Katz
Democrats, the many running for president as well as energized members of Congress, are talking big about health care again. Among other things, that means brace yourself for some jargon. Here’s your neighborhood health care nerd to help define some terms.
Various proposals are floating around, each of which would change the health care system in distinct
ways. Some, like one from Senator Bernie Sanders, would do away with all private health insurance. Some
would make small expansions in existing public programs. Some would try to cover all Americans
through a mix of different insurance types.
It can be mystifying when people call of these ideas “Medicare for all,” as some in the debate have been
doing. A glossary of terms could make the debate less confusing. Let’s start with the basics.
What is Medicare?
Medicare is a 54-year-old program that provides health insurance for Americans 65 and older, and for a few other groups of people with particular diseases or disabilities.
Traditional Medicare pays doctors and hospitals according to set prices determined by the government, and most medical providers in the United States accept it. It’s also possible to enroll in private Medicare plans that can offer additional benefits, though with a more limited set of health providers. Private plans handle Medicare drug coverage, and you can choose among options. You pay premiums each year, and you pay deductibles and co-payments when you use medical services. Because the program’s out-of-pocket
What is Medicare for all?
This increasingly popular term was coined to describe a system in which all Americans, not just older ones,
get health insurance through the government’s Medicare system.
Mr. Sanders, who prominently featured such a plan in his 2016 presidential platform and just announced he has joined the 2020 race, uses this term a lot. His plan
What is single-payer health care?
What is socialized medicine?
Critics of single-payer are particularly fond of this term, which describes a system in which the government runs not just the financing of health care – by running an insurance company like Medicare – but also manages
hospitals and employs medical providers directly. Britain’s National Health Service is an example of a
socialized system. Doctors there work for the government.The United States has its own socialized system, for military veterans. Veterans get their
insurance through the Department of Veterans Affairs, which owns hospitals; employs doctors, nurses and other medical professionals; and negotiates directly with pharmaceutical companies for drugs. In general a veteran couldn’t get coverage for routine care from a
doctor who didn’t work directly for the V.A., but recent policy changes have started to privatize more health care for veterans.There are currently no mainstream
proposals to fully socialize the United States health care system.
What’s a public option?
When lawmakers were writing the Affordable Care Act, there was an extensive debate about whether it should include a public option. The idea didn’t prevail in the end, but many Democrats now want to bring it back.
You can think of a public option as something of a compromise between a single-payer system and our
current system, in which only certain Americans now qualify for government-run programs. More people – maybe many more -could get government insurance.
But only if they wanted it. Public-option plans would allow middle-income, working-age adults to choose a public insurance plan – like Medicare or Medicaid – instead of a private insurance plan. There are various ways this could work.
Some proposals would allow individuals to pay a premium to buy a Medicare or Medicaid plan that would be the same as the insurance now available to older people, the disabled or the poor. Others would set up a new public plan, run by the government, that Americans could buy. Under most proposals, people who get federal help buying Obamacare coverage could use their government subsidies to help them buy either a private or public option. Most of the current proposals would limit access to the public option to certain groups of Americans. A bill from Senator Debbie Stabenow of Michigan and colleagues would allow only those older than 50 to buy a Medicare plan, for example. Some plans would allow only people who buy their own health insurance to choose Medicare or Medicaid as an option alongside those offered in the Obamacare exchanges. Others would also let employers choose Medicare, instead of a private health insurance company, when offering benefits to their workers. A plan from a liberal think tank, the Center for American Progress, would make the public Medicare option available to anyone who wanted to sign up.
An advantage of a public option, at least politically, is it would preserve more choice for individuals, who could stick with a private plan if they prefer. That would make it less disruptive than a single-payer plan. A downside is that keeping lots of different insurance options could undermine one of the goals of a
single-payer system, a simpler approach that would involve less money tied up in paperwork and insurance company profits.
What is universal coverage?
All of the earlier entries describe ways of organizing the health insurance system. Universal coverage is a broader goal. When people push for universal coverage,
they mean that everyone should have access to the health care system. You’ll sometimes hear politicians say that health care should be a “right.” That statement
is an endorsement of universal coverage. Most other developed countries embrace this idea, that health care
should not be only for those who can afford it. But those countries have not all embraced single-payer
There are ways to achieve universal coverage that don’t look like a single-payer system at all. Most
European countries, for example, have systems with competing private health insurance plans, along with tight regulation and government subsidies that make the premiums affordable for everyone.